If you’re visiting Culver’s for the first time (or even the tenth), choosing the right ButterBurger can be overwhelming. With multiple variations ranging from simple classics to fully loaded deluxe options, knowing what to order makes all the difference.
This guide ranks the best ButterBurger options based on taste, popularity, value, and overall experience—so you can confidently pick your next meal.
What Is a ButterBurger?
A ButterBurger is made from fresh, never frozen beef, cooked to order, and served on a lightly buttered, toasted bun. Unlike typical fast-food burgers, it’s known for its rich flavor, crispy edges, and juicy center.
🏆 Best ButterBurger Options Ranked
1. ButterBurger Cheese (Top Pick Overall)
Why it’s #1: Perfect balance of simplicity and flavor
- Fresh beef patty
- American cheese
- Buttered bun
This is the most popular choice—and for good reason. It delivers everything you expect from a burger without unnecessary extras. If you want the true Culver’s experience, start here.
👉 Best for: First-time visitors
2. ButterBurger Cheese Deluxe
Why it’s great: Adds freshness and texture
- Cheese + lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions
- Mayo for extra creaminess
The Deluxe version upgrades the classic with crisp vegetables and a more layered bite. It feels more like a “complete” burger meal.
👉 Best for: Balanced flavor lovers
3. Mushroom & Swiss ButterBurger
Why it stands out: Rich, savory, and indulgent
- Sautéed mushrooms
- Swiss cheese
This option leans gourmet compared to standard fast food. The earthy mushrooms pair perfectly with the juicy beef.
👉 Best for: Heavier, umami-rich meals
4. Bacon Deluxe ButterBurger
Why it’s popular: Everything is better with bacon
- Crispy bacon
- Cheese + deluxe toppings
It combines the Deluxe freshness with smoky bacon, making it one of the most satisfying options on the menu.
👉 Best for: Big appetites
5. Original ButterBurger (No Cheese)
Why it works: Simple and budget-friendly
- Beef patty
- Buttered bun
This is the most basic version. While it lacks cheese, it still highlights the quality of the beef.
👉 Best for: Minimalists or lower-cost orders
6. Double ButterBurger Cheese
Why it’s lower ranked: Great, but heavy
- Two beef patties
- Double cheese
It’s delicious but can feel overwhelming for some. The balance of bun-to-meat ratio gets a bit lost.
👉 Best for: Very hungry customers
⭐ Quick Comparison Table
| Burger | Best Feature | Ideal For |
|---|---|---|
| ButterBurger Cheese | Perfect balance | First-timers |
| Cheese Deluxe | Fresh toppings | Balanced meals |
| Mushroom & Swiss | Rich flavor | Gourmet lovers |
| Bacon Deluxe | Smoky + filling | Big appetites |
| Original | Simplicity | Budget choice |
| Double Cheese | Extra meat | Heavy eaters |
🔥 Best ButterBurger for Each Need
Q: What is the best ButterBurger at Culver’s?
👉 The ButterBurger Cheese is the best overall due to its perfect flavor balance and popularity.
Q: Which ButterBurger is healthiest?
👉 The Original ButterBurger (no cheese, no sauces) is the lowest in calories.
Q: Which ButterBurger is the most filling?
👉 The Double ButterBurger Cheese offers the most protein and portion size.
Q: What should first-time visitors order?
👉 Start with the ButterBurger Cheese or Cheese Deluxe.
💡 Pro Tips Before You Order
- Ask for extra crispy edges for more texture
- Customize toppings—Culver’s allows flexibility
- Pair your burger with cheese curds or frozen custard for the full experience
Final Verdict
The Culver’s ButterBurger lineup offers something for everyone—but if you want the best overall experience, the ButterBurger Cheese stands above the rest of the culver’s menu.
Whether you prefer simple, deluxe, or fully loaded, each option delivers that signature buttery, juicy flavor that keeps customers coming back.